← All posts

    How to negotiate salary and a job offer (without blowing it up)

    Jeff Baker · November 20, 2026

    The offer is the most leverage you'll ever have at that company. Here's how to counter without sounding greedy or getting the offer pulled, with scripts you can copy.

    To negotiate salary, wait until you have a written offer, thank them, research what the role pays, then counter with one specific number and a short reason. Be warm, be specific, and stop talking after you name the number. Most of the money in a negotiation comes from simply asking once, well.

    Here's the full process, the scripts, and the remote-work details nobody else covers.

    What this is based on: official state pay transparency pages from California, Colorado, New York and Washington, and BLS OEWS wage data (May 2025 estimates). Laws change and this isn't legal advice. Checked November 2026.

    The basic rules

    1. Don't negotiate before there's an offer. Early salary questions are a screening step, not a negotiation. (Here's how to answer salary expectations when they come up.)
    2. Get it in writing. A verbal "we're thinking around X" is not an offer.
    3. Always ask for time. "Can I have a day or two to review?" is normal. Nobody serious pulls an offer because you read it.
    4. Counter with one number, not a range. A range is an invitation to pay you the bottom of it.
    5. Give a reason. Market data, a competing offer, scope of the role. Not "my rent is insane" (even if it is).
    6. Negotiate once, then decide. Going back three or four times is where goodwill starts to die.

    Step 1: Know what the role actually pays

    You're not guessing. You're showing up with data.

    • BLS wage percentiles. The BLS literally has a page on using its OEWS data during salary negotiations. It gives you the 10th, 25th, median, 75th and 90th percentile wages for your occupation, by state and roughly 530 metro and nonmetro areas. The current figures are from the May 2025 estimates, so if you're using them in late 2026, assume real pay has moved a bit since.
    • The posted range. Thanks to pay transparency laws (more on those below), a lot of postings now include a range. That range is the company telling you what it budgeted.
    • Salary Coach. Our Salary Coach gives you salary estimates customized to your skills, with negotiation headroom, which is exactly the number you want in your head before you counter.

    Pay transparency laws are on your side

    You don't have to fly blind in a lot of places anymore. A few examples from the states' own pages:

    State What the official page says
    California Employers with 15 or more employees must include the pay scale in any job posting. Applicants can request the pay scale "upon reasonable request." Employers generally can't seek your salary history.
    Colorado Under the Equal Pay for Equal Work Act, employers with at least one employee in Colorado must include the pay rate (or a range) and a general description of all benefits in each job posting. "Competitive benefits" alone doesn't comply.
    New York Businesses with four or more employees must list compensation ranges in job postings. Open-ended ranges like "$17 an hour and up" aren't acceptable. The law went into effect September 17, 2023.
    Washington Employers with 15 or more employees must include a wage scale or salary range and a general description of all benefits in job postings. Employers can't ask for your wage or salary history.

    The remote-work angle: New York's FAQ says a job that "reports to a supervisor, office, or other work site in the state of New York" must include pay info, even if the person works from home somewhere else. So a remote job reporting into a New York office should show a range. Colorado goes further: its guidance says remote work "performable in Colorado or elsewhere" for a covered employer has to comply.

    These are state laws with their own details and exceptions. If you're relying on one, read your state's page or ask a lawyer. I'm a marketing guy, not your attorney.

    Step 2: Respond to the offer (without saying yes)

    When the offer comes in, be enthusiastic and noncommittal at the same time:

    Thank you so much, I'm really excited about this role and the team. Could you send the full offer in writing, including base, bonus, equity and benefits? I'd like a couple of days to review it, and I'll get back to you by [day].

    Done. You've signaled you want the job without accepting the number.

    Step 3: Make the counter

    Here's a counter you can say on a call or send by email:

    Thanks again for the offer. I'm excited about [specific thing about the role or team]. Based on my research for [role] at this level, and the [scope, skill or result] I'd bring from day one, I was hoping for a base salary of [specific number]. If we can get there, I'm ready to sign.

    That last line is doing a lot of work. It tells them closing the gap closes the deal. Only say it if it's true.

    Then stop. Let them respond. If they say they need to check, great. That's the system working.

    If you have a competing offer

    I want to be transparent: I have another offer at [number]. [Company] is my first choice because of [real reason]. Is there flexibility to get closer to that number?

    Don't invent a competing offer. Recruiters talk, and lying is how a good negotiation turns into a rescinded one.

    If they say the salary is fixed

    I understand. Is there flexibility in other parts of the package, like a sign-on bonus, an extra week of PTO, or a guaranteed compensation review at six months?

    How to negotiate a job offer (not just the salary)

    Base salary gets all the attention, but it's one line of the offer. Here's what's often on the table:

    Item How negotiable it tends to be Script angle
    Base salary Usually some room, especially below the top of the posted range Market data plus your scope
    Sign-on bonus Often easier than base, since it's one-time money "Could a sign-on bonus bridge the gap?"
    Equity Varies a lot by company and stage Ask how it's valued and what the vesting schedule is
    Start date Very negotiable Take a break between jobs if you can
    PTO Sometimes fixed by policy, sometimes not Ask, it costs them less than salary
    Title Often negotiable, matters for your next job Tie it to the actual scope
    Review date Easy yes for many companies "Can we put a six-month review in writing?"
    Remote stipend Depends on company Home office or coworking budget
    Where you can work Critical for remote roles Get the allowed countries or states in writing

    That last row is the one I care about most. "Work from anywhere" roles are not "hire from anywhere." Most remote jobs still restrict where you can live (country, state, sometimes time zone) for tax and legal reasons. If you plan to travel or move, sort it out before you sign, not after you've booked six months in Lisbon. 🌍

    Remote job offers: the location-pay trap

    Some remote companies use location-based pay bands, meaning the same job pays differently depending on where you live. Ask directly:

    Is this salary tied to a location band? If so, which band am I in, and what happens if I relocate?

    Get the answer in writing. You don't want to discover the policy when HR adjusts your salary after you move. If you're comparing offers, our digital nomad cost of living calculator shows what an income actually feels like in 89 remote-work destinations.

    Can negotiating get your offer pulled?

    It can. An offer isn't a guarantee until it's signed, and a company can decide to walk away. But a polite counter backed by data is a normal part of hiring, and recruiters generally expect it. What actually blows offers up:

    • Ultimatums ("I need X or I walk")
    • Fake competing offers
    • Going back again and again after you said you'd sign
    • Ghosting the recruiter for a week while you shop the offer around

    If a company pulls an offer because you asked once, politely, they just showed you how they'd treat you when you ask for a raise. Damn, better to find out now.

    Accepting (the right way)

    Once you've agreed:

    Thank you, I'm happy to accept. Could you send the updated offer letter with [the agreed terms] so I can sign?

    Don't resign from your current job until you have the signed offer and any contingencies (background check, references) are cleared.

    What if you skipped negotiating?

    It happens. You can't really reopen an offer you already accepted, but you can set yourself up for the next round. Keep a wins doc from day one and read how to ask for a raise about six months in.

    If you want to rehearse the counter out loud with someone who's been on the hiring side, bring it to drop-in coaching. It's live group coaching. Marisa, my co-founder and the coach behind it, worked in corporate recruiting before spending over a decade coaching people into remote careers, so Marisa knows what the person on the other end of the call is thinking.

    Frequently asked questions

    Can a job offer be rescinded for negotiating?

    It can happen, since an offer isn't guaranteed until it's signed, but a polite, researched counter is a normal part of hiring and most recruiters expect it. Offers get pulled more often over threats, ultimatums or dragging things out than over a reasonable ask.

    How much should I counter a job offer?

    Counter with one specific number based on market data for the role and the posted range, usually toward the top of that range. Don't counter with a range, because they'll pick the bottom.

    Should I negotiate salary by email or phone?

    Either works. Phone or video is better for tone; email is better if you get flustered or want to choose every word. Whichever you use, get the final offer in writing.

    What can I negotiate besides salary?

    Sign-on bonus, equity, start date, PTO, title, a guaranteed review date, a home office or coworking stipend, and for remote roles, which locations you're allowed to work from.

    Is it okay to negotiate an entry-level job offer?

    Yes. You may have less room, but asking once, politely, with a reason is normal. The worst realistic outcome is a no.

    Sources